Quick Answer
Start by matching what's already on your house. For wet, ground-level spots, James Hardie fiber cement or AZEK and PVC trim last the longest. LP SmartSide is the usual choice on newer homes with engineered siding, and cedar suits homes already sided in cedar.
When we find rotted siding during an estimate, the next question is what to replace it with. In Kansas City, most homes are built with one of a few materials, and the right choice depends on what's already on your house and how wet the area stays.
James Hardie Fiber Cement
Fiber cement is extremely durable, won't rot, and holds paint for a long time. It's a great choice for areas that see a lot of moisture and for homeowners who plan to stay put. It's heavier and takes more labor to install.
LP SmartSide Engineered Wood
LP SmartSide is common on newer Kansas City homes. It's lighter than fiber cement, resists impact well, and is the easiest way to match existing engineered siding. The key is sealing every cut edge and seam, because that's where water gets in.
Cedar
Cedar is natural wood with a classic look and natural rot resistance. It's the right match for cedar-sided homes and custom profiles, but it moves more with the seasons, so caulk and paint maintenance matter.
AZEK And PVC Trim
For trim, door frames, and areas near the ground that never fully dry out, AZEK and PVC trim are hard to beat. They won't rot and take paint well when properly prepped.
Our approach: we recommend materials based on your wants and needs, then caulk, prime, and paint everything so the repair blends in with the rest of your home. Not sure if you need a few boards or all new siding? Read paint or replace your siding.
Not Sure What Your Home Needs?
We'll show you every soft spot we find and circle each area we plan to replace on photos in your quote. See our wood rot and siding repair or request a free estimate.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can James Hardie Siding Be Painted?
Yes. Fiber cement holds paint very well. New boards come primed, and we finish them with the same paint as the rest of your house.
Does LP SmartSide Rot?
It resists rot well when every cut edge and seam is sealed. Most LP SmartSide failures we see start at unsealed edges near the ground or where water sits.
Can New Siding Boards Be Matched To My Existing Siding?
In most cases, yes. We match the profile and reveal as closely as possible, then prime and paint so the repair blends in.
Cade Zerr is the owner of Arrowhead Painting KC, leading a team with more than 35 years of combined painting experience. More about Cade