Quick Answer
Both brands make excellent top-tier exterior paint, and either will outlast a bargain brand. Prep and application matter more than the logo on the can. Our exterior warranties are tied to Sherwin-Williams lines: SuperPaint (3 years), Duration (5 years), and Emerald Rain Refresh (7 years).
Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore are the two names homeowners ask about most, and for good reason. Both make excellent professional-grade exterior paints. We use both, but Sherwin-Williams is our go-to. Here's why, and how to think about the choice.
The Short Version
Both brands make top-quality exterior paint. The product line you choose within a brand matters more than the brand itself. A premium line from either company will outperform an entry-level line from the other. And no paint, however good, makes up for poor prep.
Why We Lead With Sherwin-Williams
- Consistent, proven products. We know exactly how SuperPaint, Duration, and Emerald Rain Refresh apply, cover, and hold up on Kansas City homes because we use them every week.
- Local availability. Sherwin-Williams has stores across the metro, so we can get product, color matches, and touch-up paint quickly.
- A clear good-better-best lineup that maps neatly to our 3-, 5-, and 7-year warranty packages.
- Matching caulks. PowerHouse and SherMax elastomeric caulks pair with the coatings we use.
Our Sherwin-Williams Exterior Lineup
SuperPaint®
A reliable, proven exterior paint with good adhesion and color retention. It's a solid choice for budget-minded repaints and homes in good condition. Paired with PowerHouse caulk and our 3-year warranty.
Duration®
A thicker, more flexible film that hides better and stands up to weather. It's our most popular option and a great fit for most Kansas City homes. Paired with SherMax elastomeric caulk and a 5-year warranty.
Emerald® Rain Refresh
Sherwin-Williams' top-tier exterior coating. It's designed to shed dirt when it rains so the house stays cleaner, and it offers excellent color retention. It's ideal for darker colors, full-sun exposures, and homeowners planning to stay long-term. Paired with SherMax caulk and our 7-year warranty.
When Benjamin Moore Makes Sense
Benjamin Moore makes excellent exterior paints, and some homeowners love a specific Benjamin Moore color or have used it on previous projects. If you prefer it, we're happy to spec a comparable Benjamin Moore product. Your quote will show exactly what we'll use.
Color Matching Across Brands
Found a color you love in the other brand? Paint stores can color-match across brands, though results vary slightly with sheen and base. We always recommend a sample on your actual siding before committing.
What Matters More Than The Brand
- Prep: washing, scraping, caulking, and priming
- Repairs: replacing rotted wood instead of painting over it
- Application: the right film thickness, applied by experienced painters
- Conditions: painting in the right weather
That's why every Arrowhead exterior package includes the same prep, no matter which paint you choose. See our exterior painting process and warranty details.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Lasts Longer, Sherwin-Williams Or Benjamin Moore?
Comparing their top lines, the difference is small. Prep, caulk, and how the paint is applied affect lifespan far more.
Can A Benjamin Moore Color Be Made In Sherwin-Williams Paint?
Usually, yes. Paint stores can color-match closely, though we always check a sample on the house first because matches aren't perfect.
Do You Use Other Paint Brands?
Yes. We supply all major paint brands, so if you have a favorite product, just tell us during your estimate.
Cade Zerr is the owner of Arrowhead Painting KC, leading a team with more than 35 years of combined painting experience. More about Cade